France vs Spain
Two retirement contenders on one comparable scale. Same published formula, same source-cited data; every fact below keeps its citation.
Axis by axis
- HealthcareFrance +17
- Retiree visaSpain +50
- AffordabilityTied
- SafetySpain +24
- ClimateTied
- Expat communityTied
The facts, side by side
Each value links to the exact source it was verified against.
Long-Stay Visitor Visa (VLS-TS visiteur), the visa de long sejour valant titre de sejour, visitor category
Applicants must show stable resources of at least around 1,400 euros net per month for an individual (roughly the French minimum wage, SMIC), or approximately 2,100 euros net per month for a couple.
~EUR 2,400/mo single (400% of IPREM, about EUR 28,800/yr), plus ~EUR 600/mo (100% IPREM) per dependent family member.
Long-stay visitor visa applicants must hold private health insurance valid in France covering medical costs and hospitalization for the full duration of stay; standard travel insurance is not accepted. After legal residence is established, expats may later access the public system.
Full private cover is required for the visa; as a public-system proxy, the Convenio Especial costs ~EUR 157/mo for over-65s (vs ~EUR 60/mo under-65), and private plans for a 65-year-old are broadly in that range or higher.
Estimated single-person costs around 1,500 to 1,800 euros per month including modest rent; consumer prices run a few percent below the US and rent is substantially cheaper.
~$1,900-2,600 single incl. rent (Madrid single-person costs ~EUR 826/mo excl. rent plus central 1-bed rent); cheaper outside the capital.
Rent in France averages far below the US, with rent prices roughly 80% higher in the US than in France; a one-bedroom city-centre apartment averages about 761 euros in France versus about 1,434 euros in the US.
Madrid 1-bed city-centre rent averages ~EUR 1,417/mo (Numbeo, 2026); expat-favourite cities like Valencia and Alicante run well below Madrid.
Oceanic in the west and north, Mediterranean in the south, semi-continental in the east and centre
Under the treaty, distributions from US-qualified retirement accounts (401(k), IRA) and US Social Security are generally taxable in the US rather than France, but must still be declared in France. This is a notable advantage versus many other countries; specifics depend on account type and individual circumstances, so professional tax advice is recommended.
Yes, Spain taxes the worldwide income of tax residents, including foreign private pensions, at progressive rates of 19%-47%. US Social Security is generally taxed only in the US, and government pensions typically only in the source country.
Full France profileFull Spain profileAll 40 countries, ranked